Although everything about San Diego Comic-Con has increased in competitiveness over the years, Hotelpocalypse really became the monster that we know today just a few short years ago. Since then, though, it’s become what we consider to be the most stressful sale relating to Comic-Con that there is – yes, even compared to Open Registration badge sales, in which we estimate that you have only a 6% chance of scoring a badge.
That’s because, to steal a line from our staffer James Riley, unlike badge sales, the hotel sale is similar to the stress of the last 30 seconds of an eBay auction, but with none of the immediate gratification. At least in the badge sale, you may leave disappointed, but you have your answer of whether you scored a badge or not in roughly two hours. In the general hotel sale? You won’t know how well you did for days.
And even more so than any other year, how well you did and how many other people whose speed you beat, is completely up in the air, and completely unpredictable.
At 9AM PT, the link provided by Travel Planners and Comic-Con International was to open to to the General Hotel form, where attendees could rank their top six hotel choices in preference, and fill in all of their required information (like name, e-mail, arrival and departure date, how many people would be staying in the room, etc.) Things got off to a very bad start from the second the form opened, when most users, including us, reported the form taking longer than normal to load. How long it took varied person to person, with some reporting 20-30 seconds, and some reporting minutes. This obviously slowed down everyone’s time in being able to submit the form at all.
That form took awhile to load and submit… But we got through. Good luck to everyone else! Now we wait.
— SDCC Unofficial Blog (@SD_Comic_Con) March 24, 2015
Due to the slow load, this is the first time we've submitted with an over 2:00 time in years. #SDCC #HotelDraw
— Pink Bunny (@pinkbunnyr) March 24, 2015
@SD_Comic_Con 9:03. Took over a minute for the page to load.
— Stephanie Shamblin (@UndeadStephanie) March 24, 2015
Ack. Hotel form didn't load til 9:02am for me. Ack! #sdcc #Hotelpocalypse
— Lisa Will (@dustchick) March 24, 2015
@SD_Comic_Con finished in under two minutes, spent at least 20 seconds waiting for the form to load
— AJ Cardamenis (@borntorun1975) March 24, 2015
But that was only the beginning. It took a few minutes for news to filter down that users actually saw two different forms when they submitted – either the “good” form, with a drop down menu of all the hotel choices, that looked like this:
Or the “bad” form, which didn’t include a drop down menu, but rather a scrollable text box. You could select one, or all six hotels if you held Ctrl down on your keyboard, but there was no way to rank them. Here’s a look at the bad form, from Twitter user SDCCIndiego:
That wasn’t the only problem with the bad form, though. The normal form has safeguards in place, so that you can’t accidentally press enter and submit your form before you’ve filled out all of the required information. That safeguard was gone on the “bad” form, leading to several users reporting to accidentally submitting their form before they’d entered in their name, room preferences, or other information. We haven’t seen much chatter from people on Twitter about the problem, but on the Friends of CCI forum, some users reported being able to accidentally submit without all of their information complete:
We reached out to Travel Planners shortly after we realized there had been a problem, and were told that we should direct attendees to call, so that they could take down names and contact information for anyone with a problem. However, at the time, the company possibly didn’t realize just how widespread the issue was, and were soon inundated with calls. This led to a different solution from Travel Planners: Anyone who had received the “bad” hotel form was e-mailed on Tuesday evening with a new link, to be able to fill out their e-mail (to match with the original submission time stamp and other information) and to rank their six hotel choices. Here’s a look at that form:
Although that’s likely to help the majority of users, it doesn’t address some key problems. Namely, time stamps, and how the form affected them. Most users with the bad form reported that it took them much longer than normal, even without the added consideration of the slow load time, to fill out their information, because the form was different, and did not behave as expected (or directed, as there was no way to rank six hotels).
Yea my problem was that I never hit submit until I had a working form, which was 8 minutes after 9. Late time stamp.#SDCC #Hotelpocalypse
— Tony B Kim @ AwesomeCon (@Crazy4ComicCon) March 24, 2015
@travelplanners_ please take into consideration time taken trying to figure how to select hotels on the bad form for submission time! #sdcc
— Miss Mercury (@AngiesMomma) March 24, 2015
It also doesn’t address another problem: That some users (which we believe to be a very small amount) could have accidentally submitted their form some 20-30 seconds after the form went live, at least with their e-mails filled out, but with no other information, and that Travel Planners would still honor their original timestamp. Although we can understand the concern, because this is a Comic-Con sale and every possibly advantage someone has can mean the difference between you getting a hotel/badge/exclusive and being completely shut out, we don’t believe that this is a widespread issue. Further, there’s a very real possibility that since the form Travel Planners had users with the bad form fill out only included hotel rankings, that they could be discarding any forms without room information (such as departure/arrival dates and room preference), as it’s not enough information to assign a room. Travel Planners has yet to make any kind of statement on those forms, though, so we likely won’t know how those with that issue are dealt with until hotel confirmations go out.
We’ve heard that hotel reservation confirmations could start going out on Thursday night or Friday morning due to the issues (which is at least close to the promised March 26 date), but we only know one thing for sure: When they do, just like every year, thousands of attendees aren’t going to be happy. This year, though, there’s a lot more than usual to be unhappy about.
What was your experience like during the General Hotel Sale? Let us know in the comments.